| Children |
| | 1. Hannah Marsh Sibley, b. 13 Jun 1732, Sutton, Worcester Co., MA , d. 2 Jul 1819, Douglas, Worcester Co., MA  |
| | 2. Ruth Sibley, b. 4 Jun 1734, Sutton, Worcester Co., MA , d. 23 Mar 1755, Sutton, Worcester Co., MA  |
| | 3. Dorcas Sibley, b. 7 Jul 1736, Sutton, Worcester Co., MA , d. 9 May 1841, Braintree, Orange Co., VT  |
| | 4. Lydia Sibley, b. 30 May 1738, Sutton, Worcester Co., MA , d. 11 Jul 1738, Sutton, Worcester Co., MA  |
| | 5. John Sibley, Jr, b. 5 Nov 1740, Sutton, Worcester Co., MA , d. 1824, Sutton, Worcester Co., MA  |
| | 6. Abner Sibley, b. 5 Mar 1743, Sutton, Worcester Co., MA , d. 7 Apr 1743, Sutton, Worcester Co., MA  |
| | 7. Abner Sibley, b. 9 Apr 1744, Sutton, Worcester Co., MA , d. 5 May 1822, Sutton, Worcester Co., MA  |
| | 8. Elisha Sibley, b. 24 Feb 1746, Sutton, Worcester Co., MA , d. 17 May 1830, Bennington, Bennington Co., VT  |
| | 9. David Sibley, b. 14 Aug 1750, Sutton, Worcester Co., MA , d. Bef 1850 |
| | 10. Stephen Sibley, b. 14 Aug 1750, Sutton, Worcester Co., MA , d. 1778 |
| | 11. Peter Sibley, b. 13 May 1751, Sutton, Worcester Co., MA , d. 10 Sep 1826 |
|